top of page

The new politics of community power

Writer: Municipal Enquiry
Municipal Enquiry
11 minutes ago
7 min read

Something is changing. After years of campaigning by grassroots organisations, community development practitioners and progressive movements, the developing alternatives to our extractive economy are the subject of more attention than ever in public policy and investment.

This reflects the realities of economic, social and cultural inequality, which are becoming increasingly difficult to ignore as late-stage capitalism continues to bear down on those who have been most marginalised. It also reflects a growing recognition that people working at the grassroots have been creating alternatives together in their communities for decades.

As that recognition grows, mainstream institutions have been using the term ‘community power’ and articulating it as a homogenising catch-all for this landscape of grassroots activity and community-led alternatives.

But this doesn't mean that the actors now assembling around the 'community power' agenda all share the same goals. As the stakes get higher and resources are fought over more fiercely, community power is becoming a focus of political contestation.

But our concern is not simply with who gets to define community power - it is with how it might be possible, in our present situation, to build a progressive and far-reaching agenda for putting it into practice.

There’s no question that the term is being invoked in aspirational ways in the context of the National Lottery Community Fund’s £175m Community Wealth Fund (jointly funded through the Dormant Assets Scheme) and its £100m, ten-year Community Power Fund; Great British Energy’s Local Power Plan, backed by up to £1bn to expand local and community-owned energy; the government’s Youth Matters Fund, representing an investment of over £400m; and, of course, the government’s £5.8bn Pride in Place programme, which represents a commitment of up to £20 million of funding and support for 284 places over ten years.

But what happens when practices and ideas evolved predominantly through grassroots struggles and democratising movements are taken up by mainstream institutions?


Does it change the institutions, get absorbed into familiar ways of doing things, or become the focus of continuous struggles between competing visions and interests?

For some, community power will mean making established institutions and longstanding processes more participatory, responsive and effective.  

For others, it means fundamentally redistributing ownership and control, building autonomous democratic institutions and changing the conditions through which power is exercised.  

These ambitions may overlap, but they are not the same thing and one doesn’t necessarily lead to the other.  

And as community power becomes more established, the struggle over which vision prevails and whether collective energy and resources get absorbed back into strengthening the status quo, or directed into the work of creating much more progressive alternatives, will become increasingly consequential.  

Imagine if, ten years from now, the principal legacy of this current upsurge in investment is not stronger communities, but a realignment of local governance around a set of intermediaries, some existing and some new, who speak the language of community power but use it to accrue resources and consolidate their position.

This is not inevitable - community development practitioners have spent decades arguing that: 

  • participation is not the same as power;

  • local responsibility without resources simply shifts the burdens of austerity;

  • stronger institutions do not necessarily mean stronger communities;

  • and, greater support for community power must confront racism, classism and the politics of divide and rule.

The new landscape of ‘community power’ therefore raises deep-rooted and perennial questions about who, beyond the field of governmental and institutional power, defines, organises and benefits from this trend in investment.

Beyond participation: building collective capacity

The expansion of the ‘community power’ agenda presents an opening to move the debate on in progressive ways: from participation to collective capacity, from short-term projects to enduring infrastructure, and from community representation to democratic ownership and control.  

This is the new politics of community power.

For us, this means thinking about three things together:


First, material power. Communities most marginalised by our current economic system need access to land, buildings, funding and economic infrastructure. They need to be able to acquire and govern assets, develop democratic forms of ownership and build economic activity that retains and circulates resources locally. Community power, without this, risks becoming an invitation to continue to participate in decisions about resources that remain firmly in somebody else's hands.

Second, the power of knowledge. People need the means to critically engage with the conditions shaping their lives, develop and share their own knowledge, and learn to build effective organisations and act together. This means taking learning, popular education, community research and peer-to-peer support seriously. But it also means recognising people's capacity and ability to create, interpret and shape the cultural life of their communities and wider society: by voicing their experiences, developing their own place-specific historical narratives and understandings, and contributing to the ideas and hopeful alternatives which can fuel collective cultural life.  

A learning infrastructure isn't an optional extra - it can support people to translate private problems into public issues, develop people’s capacity to organise and build more effective forms of community-led collective action.  

Third, democratic power. Communities need their own spaces and institutions through which people can autonomously convene, make decisions, coordinate action and hold each other to account. Cultural organising and organisations also matter: they can provide the means through which people can express themselves and create shared identities. The aim is to collectively build democratic forms through which people can exercise power for themselves on an ongoing basis.

These are inseparable and mutually reinforcing dimensions.  

So, what would it mean to bring these things together? We believe there’s a need to start talking about socialised community development.

By this we mean treating the collective capacity to organise, learn, own and govern as something communities can develop, shape and sustain together.  

The means through which these capacities are developed should become shared, long-term infrastructure that communities collectively govern and own. Not something that’s reinvented in each neighbourhood through short-term projects or purchased from consultants.  

This would include adult learning and community research; sustained support for grassroots organising and cultural activity; shared expertise and resources; community-owned social, cultural and economic infrastructure; and democratic institutions connecting communities.

In other words, investment in community development needs to be understood as investment in collectively owned and governed infrastructure through which communities can develop and exercise democratic, cultural and economic power.

Who is community power for?

To make the above happen some thorny questions need to be answered about how the new ‘community power’ agenda is developing.  

One important question concerns the kinds of democratic institutions that could connect communities without becoming another layer of intermediaries.  

Local and national organisations can be valuable in providing expertise, connecting communities with resources and helping navigate institutions. But there is a danger that intermediary organisations become the pivotal recipients of investment and, as funding expands, the authorised representatives of communities, or even proxies for community power itself.

We could end up with stronger intermediary organisations and more elaborate systems of participation, without significantly increasing people's capacity to organise independently.

Intermediation is not a problem in itself - the question is whether intermediaries are accountable to communities and help extend their ability to act or accrue the resources and authority to act on their behalf.  

Another concern is professionalisation. Complex funding, formal governance and programme management currently favour organisations with existing institutional connections and resources.

If this continues, unconstituted groups, grassroots campaigns and less established and marginalised communities will continue to struggle to get a foothold - despite being the groups already doing the work and the most in need of investment and support.

The contemporary upsurge in right-wing identity politics also can't be ignored. Racism needs to be forcefully opposed by any approach to the community power agenda that claims to be progressive. That means community power cannot strengthen local identities and institutions at the expense of those who are marginalised or excluded; or be uncritical and complacent about political actors seeking to appropriate its language while advancing opposing agendas.

Some of those involved in shaping the community power agenda hold political visions at odds with inclusive, democratically governed and egalitarian communities. The idea of socialised community development, grounded in collective ownership, cultural empowerment and democratic control, is unlikely to sit comfortably with these outlooks.

And what about the relationship between community power and the wider economy? 

Communities may be encouraged to become more resilient, innovative, entrepreneurial and self-reliant while the structures producing inequality remain untouched.  

Equity and economic justice therefore need to be guiding principles of a progressive community power agenda. Rather than more interventions that simply help people manage the consequences of economic extraction, declining public provision and concentrated ownership, the focus should be on naming these conditions directly and supporting people to build alternatives.

Partnerships and expertise shouldn’t be rejected outright, but the question of how arrangements enable the transfer of power and help realise community self-organisation,greater autonomy, equality and inclusion must be paramount.

If arrangements lead to communities being increasingly dependent on their loyalty to top-down programmes and organisations that act on their behalf, rather than strengthening people's ability to act for themselves, then they should be rejected.  

What would it take?

If this investment is to lead somewhere progressive, we need to prioritise what currently remains marginal in policy and practice.

This means resourcing grassroots organisations and informal networks already working in these socialised and progressive ways, rather than assuming new boards and delivery partnerships are the best starting point.  

It means investing in learning, popular education and cultural activity as core community development infrastructure, not ancillary activities.  

Funding needs to relate to lasting community ownership and control of assets. 

And, vitally, it means supporting communities to build their own democratic institutions through which they can belong, exercise decision-making rights, govern shared assets and communicate their collective capacities beyond individual neighbourhoods.

This need to share beyond individual neighbourhood programmes means communities also need ways to connect, exchange knowledge, develop common demands, cultivate shared cultural understandings and identities, and - crucially - exercise collective influence at regional and national levels. Whilst intermediary institutions might help facilitate these relationships, the connections and democratic relationships between communities should not be channelled through them.  

To build power, communities need democratic relationships and institutions through which they can federate their capacities without losing autonomy. Without this, local activity will remain fragmented and precarious, while the institutions and economic interests shaping people's lives continue to operate at a much greater scale, beyond democratic control.

What we need now

The mainstreaming of community power creates an important opening, but it doesn't settle the question of what community power is for.

That's why we now need a progressive political agenda that assembles around the idea of socialised community development: a commitment to building collectively governed resources, organisations and democratic institutions that support communities to build their power together, connect and federate their capacities, and exercise influence beyond individual neighbourhoods.  

This will take more than new funding programmes or better-designed participation. This new politics of community power is ultimately about changing who has the power to shape, own and govern the conditions of our collective lives.

To do this we need a stronger and much better resourced grassroots movement capable of shaping, building and governing this infrastructure, and of organising the collective power needed to make this progressive vision of community power a reality.



Nick Mahony & Frances Northrop, Municipal Enquiry, November 2026


 
 
 

Recent Posts

See All
We need to talk about Pride in Place

A friend who runs a grassroots group recently messaged about Pride of Place . She lives in one of the priority areas and had only just heard it was a thing due to her Ward Councillor posting on Facebo

 
 
 

Comments


© 2020 by Municipal Enquiry

bottom of page